Why Isn't My Tustin Home Selling?

Short answer: In almost every case, the price is too high for the current market. Tustin's market is split: 31.2% of homes sell above list, while 39.4% of listings have cut price, up 17.7 points from a year ago. Buyers are still buying in Tustin. They're skipping listings priced above recent sold comps, and 7%+ mortgage rates have made them even less forgiving.

Updated October 6, 2026

Tustin market diagnosis

The 5 reasons Tustin listings go stale

1. You priced off last spring or off active listings. Tustin's median is down 3% year over year. Active listings show what sellers hope to get, not what buyers pay.
2. Rates moved after you listed. Rates rose from 6.66% in late August to above 7% by late September (Realtor.com). A buyer approved for a $1.2M purchase in August may now qualify for noticeably less.
3. Your listing falls into the wrong search filter. Most buyers search in round-number price bands. A home listed at $1,215,000 doesn't show up for a buyer whose search tops out at $1.2M.
4. The presentation didn't match the price. At more than $1M, buyers expect the home to be move-in ready, and they expect the photos to show it.
5. No urgency. Without an offer deadline, buyers wait for you to cut.

How do I fix a listing that's been sitting?

• Make one meaningful price adjustment, not a series of small ones. Several small cuts tell buyers you'll keep dropping. One correction to sold-comp value resets their attention.
• Re-launch with an offer date. Set a clear deadline 7–10 days after the new price.
• Offer a rate buydown credit instead of more price cuts. With rates at 7.28%, a credit that lowers the buyer's rate can do more for their monthly payment than the same dollars off the price.
• Pre-inspect. Hand buyers a clean report up front. That takes away the reason they'd renegotiate after the inspection.
• Get the disclosures right. As of 2026, California sellers must disclose known smoking or vaping residue (AB 455) and any digitally altered listing photos (AB 723) (Verity NHD).

How much should I drop my price?

Base it on the gap between your list price and the last 90 days of sold comps, adjusted for condition, lot, and upgrades. Don't use a percentage rule. If you've had showings but no offers for 3 weeks, buyers have already told you your price is wrong. Ask for a property-level comp analysis, not a city-level average.

FAQ

How long does it take to sell a house in Tustin?

The median Tustin home sold in 42 days for the three months ending August 2026, per Redfin. Average homes went pending in about 47 days and sold about 1% below list.

Should I take my Tustin home off the market and relist?

Only if you're making a real change to price, condition, or marketing. Relisting the same home at the same price usually doesn't fool buyers, and the listing history follows the property.

Why are so many Tustin homes reducing their price?

Tustin's share of listings with price drops rose 17.7 points year over year to 39.4% in August 2026, per Redfin. Prices are down about 3% year over year, and mortgage rates rose above 7% in September.

Is it a bad time to sell in Tustin?

No. 31.2% of Tustin homes still sell above list, and the sale-to-list ratio is 99.5%. Right now the Tustin market rewards sellers who price correctly from day one.

About the author: Shane Boukorras is a real estate advisor with The Boukorras Group at Real Broker (CA DRE 02066136), serving buyers and sellers across Orange County, the Inland Empire, and LA County. Want a property-level comp analysis for your home or a home you're considering? Reach out to The Boukorras Group.

Market data cited is the most recent available as of the update date; figures change monthly. Payment estimates are illustrative principal-and-interest calculations, not loan quotes. Not tax or legal advice.

← All articles